Non-Candy
Home
/
Store
/
Non-Candy
Refine by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Filters
Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Show items
Show items
Flamin Hot Cheetos Plush
Flamin Hot Cheetos Plush
$37.00
Add to Bag
Gamer Plush Pillow
Gamer Plush Pillow
$21.00
Add to Bag
Garlic Shrimp Doritos (Taiwan)
Garlic Shrimp Doritos (Taiwan)
$3.69
Add to Bag
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape Plush
Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape Plush
$37.00
Add to Bag
Jelly Belly Squishy Toy
Jelly Belly Squishy Toy
$9.99
Add to Bag
Lays (China) 70g
Lays (China) 70g
Multiple Flavors Available
$4.50
Add to Bag
Lays (Taiwan) 34g
Lays (Taiwan) 34g
$3.69
Add to Bag
Lifesavers Packaging Plush
Lifesavers Packaging Plush
$37.00
Add to Bag
Lifesavers Purple Plush
Lifesavers Purple Plush
$28.00
Add to Bag
M&M Packaging Plush
M&M Packaging Plush
$37.00
Add to Bag
Sold out
Mini Sour Patch Kid Plush
Mini Sour Patch Kid Plush
$13.00
Out of stock
OMG Bubble Stretch Slime
OMG Bubble Stretch Slime
$6.99
Add to Bag
Pringles Packaging Plush
Pringles Packaging Plush
$37.00
Add to Bag
Rainbow Twizzlers Packaging Plush
Rainbow Twizzlers Packaging Plush
$40.00
Add to Bag
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Packaging Plush
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Packaging Plush
$39.00
Add to Bag
Reese's Pieces Packaging Plush
Reese's Pieces Packaging Plush
$37.00
Add to Bag
Scentsational Butter Slime
Scentsational Butter Slime
Multiple Options Available
$5.99
Add to Bag
Skittles Packaging Plush
Skittles Packaging Plush
$37.00
Add to Bag
Snickers Candy Microbead Plush
Snickers Candy Microbead Plush
$15.00
Add to Bag
Sour Patch Kids Character Plush
Sour Patch Kids Character Plush
$21.00
Add to Bag
Sold out
Sour Patch Kids Packaging Plush
Sour Patch Kids Packaging Plush
$37.00
Out of stock
Sold out
Sour Patch Kids Squishy
Sour Patch Kids Squishy
$6.99
Out of stock
Sour Skittles Packaging Plush
Sour Skittles Packaging Plush
$37.00
Add to Bag
Starbursts Mini Packaging Plush
Starbursts Mini Packaging Plush
$15.00
Add to Bag
Swedish Fish Packaging Plush
Swedish Fish Packaging Plush
$37.00
Add to Bag
Swedish Fish Squishy Toy
Swedish Fish Squishy Toy
$7.99
Add to Bag
Twix Candy Microbead Plush
Twix Candy Microbead Plush
$15.00
Add to Bag
Twizzlers Packaging Plush
Twizzlers Packaging Plush
$40.00
Add to Bag
VanHoltens Big Papa Pickle
VanHoltens Big Papa Pickle
$2.99
Add to Bag
VanHoltens Mega Chamoy Pickle
VanHoltens Mega Chamoy Pickle
$3.59
Add to Bag
VanHoltens Warheads Blue Raspberry Pickle
VanHoltens Warheads Blue Raspberry Pickle
$2.99
Add to Bag
Sold out
Vlasic Pickle Balls
Vlasic Pickle Balls
$3.49
Out of stock
Skip to main content
Menu
Questions?
Shop All
Candy Salad
Christmas
Candy Buffets
Baskets & Bouquets
Trending
International
Location
FAQ
